Awhile back I reviewed the waterliner’s from em cosmetics and was disappointed by them. They claim that the waterliner won’t budge, through I found that it started to disappear and smudge after just a few hours of wear. My biggest disappointment was the packaging. While I liked that you don’t have to sharpen the pencils, the eye liner was so small that it broke easily. One of the liners that I received came broken and the others started to break with use. My best friend, who bought some during the same sale that I did, had the same complaint. Because of how easily the liner breaks, I didn’t think it was worth the price, but I absolutely loved the color of one: Bronze Kiss.